Jeff Camp

Jeff Camp

Nearly half a million of California'due south voters are teachers. Like other voters, they will shortly have to decide how to mark their November ballots. They will certainly scratch their heads over Propositions 30 and 38, competing measures that would ease the damage of four years of steady budget cuts.

Should teachers vote for Prop 38, which would bring significant new money to each school and provide funding for preschools? Or for should they vote for Prop 30, which would bring less money to instruction – but has the backing of the governor?

The California Teachers Clan (CTA), the state'due south largest teachers union, has committed to support the governor's measure, and has officially taken a neutral position on Proposition 38. But every bit the CTA's top leaders fan out to campaign this calendar month in lieu of their usual quarterly coming together, one has to wonder if their hearts will be in it. When it comes to sustaining funding, either mensurate would do for the moment, and Prop 38 would plant a longer period of commitment.

A puzzling choice: Prop 30, Prop 38 or both?

A puzzling pick: Prop 30, Prop 38 or both?

The CTA'due south State Quango is an elected body of nearly 800 representatives that normally meets four times a year. State Council members are union members with sufficient interest in union issues to take time out for this sort of thing, elected past those with sufficient involvement in spousal relationship issues to vote. It'due south a big group. Usually, the State Council convenes in the ballroom of the Westin Bonaventure Hotel in Los Angeles, a clangorous 26,108-foursquare-pes infinite that may be the only meeting space in the state big enough to accommodate it. For perspective, only two parliamentary bodies in the world have more members than the CTA Land Quango: China'due south National People'due south Congress (3,000) and the United Kingdom's House of Lords (827).

Making decisions in such a large torso is no like shooting fish in a barrel task. Considering it is so large, the CTA State Council tin can only encounter occasionally. Its meetings are often raucous, and divisions show. Nimble changes in position are out of the question.

When the State Council set up its neutral position on Prop 38 in the summer, the politics of the moment were quite different. The issue at the time was whether to support the governor's ballot measure or to back up yet another measure promoted by the California Federation of Teachers (CFT), CTA'southward friendly competitor for wedlock affiliation. Supporting three measures was unthinkable, and there was uncertainty at the time that Prop 38's backers would put frontwards the money necessary for a serious entrada. When the time came for a vote, the Land Council chose to cast its lot with the governor.

Normally, the California State PTA aligns with the CTA on ballot questions, but in this instance they have not done then – the Country PTA supports just Prop 38, every bit does Instruction Trust-West. Meanwhile, the entrada for Proposition 38 is proving quite well-funded afterwards all, with a war chest of near $30 1000000 to make its case to voters.

The governor sees Proposition 38 as an unfortunate lark. He wants voters to pass Proposition xxx, which aside from four years of aid for the General Fund besides includes constitutional "realignment" provisions that would permanently shift some of the responsibility for public condom, health, and social service programs from Sacramento to the counties.

Voters with an appetite for detail can revel in the similarities and differences between the measures by studying the well-crafted comparison canvas created by Mary Perry. However, many education-related organizations including the California School Boards Clan, Children Now, and Educate Our State, accept endorsed both measures. This position seems to be gaining traction. In a nod to "When Harry Met Emerge," Educate Our State is calling on California voters to back up both measures. They call this a "yes! yes!" position. [Note: The link is for mature audiences only.]

The most emotionally packed arguments in the campaign for Prop xxx relate to the disturbing prospect of automatic "trigger cuts" to pedagogy. If Prop xxx fails, the pedagogy budget volition automatically exist cutting, and those cuts will be passed to school districts. Backers of Prop 38 call this "hostage taking." If passed, Prop 38 would leave the Legislature with plenty of chapters to fill gaps.

In all the back and along well-nigh which ballot measure does a better job, information technology is significant to annotation the extent of understanding: (1) there is a pressing need for additional funding to educate California's children; and (2) a voter initiative is necessary to obtain it. These ii measures are quite dissimilar, neither is perfect, and certainly there will be plenty of unintended consequences. But virtually advocates are burying their differences in the interest of passing something rather than nothing. If neither passes, the trigger cuts will take effect, and the odds of a rescue from Sacramento'southward lawmakers seem remote.

Once upon a fourth dimension, initiatives were imagined as an unusual "prophylactic valve" to permit voters to serve equally legislators of last resort. Just the structure of California authorities has stood this imagined model on its caput. Initiatives can laissez passer with a well-funded entrada and a simple majority vote. Legislation is harder. Bills involving coin must pass 2 legislative bodies past a ii/3 vote in each, and then secure the signature of the governor.

(For background on why California's funding for public education has fallen so far behind the rest of the United States, go here.)

Jeff Military camp is the main author of Ed100.org, a primer on education reform options in California. He co-chairs the Education Circle of Total Circle Fund, an arrangement that coordinates small-scale teams of volunteers working in back up of great nonprofit organizations that need a little help to get to the side by side level, whatever that may exist. A visual summary of Ed100 can be constitute at here .

To get more reports like this 1, click hither to sign up for EdSource's no-cost daily electronic mail on latest developments in teaching.